In-House Developer vs WordPress Agency: Which Should You Hire?
Get Your Free Website Audit
($3,000 Value)
- Uncover performance issues
- Identify SEO opportunities
- Security gaps, and quick wins
Table of Contents
- Why Hire an In-House WordPress Developer?
- Why Hire a WordPress Agency?
- When to Hire a WordPress Agency?
- When to Hire a WordPress Freelancer?
- Conclusion
- Ready to Hire a Trusted WordPress Agency?
Hiring an in-house web developer in Australia costs $85,000 to $105,000 in base salary. That is not what it costs you.
Add 12% superannuation, four weeks annual leave, personal leave, workers compensation, payroll tax and equipment, and the fully loaded cost of a mid-level developer lands closer to $155,000 to $195,000 a year. Base salary understates the real number by 35 to 55 percent.
That is one person, with one skill set, and no cover when they take leave.
A WordPress agency in Australia typically runs from $1,250 to $10,000-plus a month depending on scope. At WP Creative, care plans start at $2,500 a month. For that you get seasoned WordPress developers, designers, QA and technical SEO specialists rather than a single hire.
But choosing between an in-house developer, a WordPress agency, or a freelancer isn’t always a one-size-fits-all decision. In this guide, we’ll break down when it makes sense to hire a WordPress agency, an in-house developer, or a freelancer.
Running an agency and reselling development to your own clients rather than buying it for yourself? That is a different decision. Our guide to choosing a white label web development partner covers it.
Why Hire an In-House WordPress Developer?
Here are the best reasons to opt for an in-house WordPress developer for your business.
1. You want complete control of your project
When you have an in-house developer, you call the shots. No waiting on external teams, no competing priorities. You get real-time updates, direct oversight, and the ability to tweak things whenever you need.
It’s like having a personal chef instead of ordering takeout. Everything is customised to your taste, exactly when you want it. You can also control the process as you will be directly overseeing the developer.
2. You are working on multiple projects over a long period of time
If your business relies on continuous web development, hiring in-house makes sense. An agency might handle multiple clients at once, but your developer is focused 100% on your projects.
If you have multiple projects in the pipeline or even when you’re working on a single project and have work that could take over a year, hiring a developer is the better choice.
Whether you need website redesigns, feature upgrades, or new integrations, you’ll always have someone on hand who knows your systems inside and out.
3. You need lots of activity every day on your project
Some websites need daily updates, troubleshooting, and performance tweaks. If that sounds like yours, an in-house developer ensures nothing slips through the cracks.
Instead of waiting for agency support, you get instant action. Need a quick fix? A new feature? A content update? It’s all handled on the spot. It makes sense to hire someone who works in-house in this case, as there might be a gap when you work with an agency, as compared to having someone in-house.
4. You require continuous communication
With an in-house developer, communication is instant. You can brainstorm ideas, resolve issues, and get updates without the back-and-forth delays.
You get immediate feedback and real-time collaboration. It’s teamwork at its best; fast, efficient, and always in sync with your goals. So, depending on the project, consider whether you would want to communicate with the developer on a regular basis and make your decision accordingly.
5. You are concerned about project confidentiality
When your website involves sensitive business data or proprietary systems, security is a top priority. Hiring in-house means fewer risks. Your developer is part of your company, working under your policies and guidelines.
Unlike freelancers or agencies juggling multiple clients, your in-house team is dedicated solely to your business. This means greater control over data protection and peace of mind knowing your information stays in trusted hands.
Why Hire a WordPress Agency?
Here are the best reasons to bring in a WordPress development agency rather than hiring.
Slow website wasting your marketing spend?
- Uncover performance issues
- Identify SEO opportunities
- Security gaps, and quick wins
1. WordPress agencies are cost-effective
Hiring a quality WordPress agency in Australia can cost as little as $2,500 per month, giving you access to an entire team for far less than a full-time salary.
WordPress agencies are extremely cost-effective when compared to in-house developers.
If you hire a WordPress developer for your website, you will be paying them a monthly retainer. In addition, there will be maintenance costs, accommodation costs, and upskill costs.
An agency, in turn, comes with a team of experts that includes more than just the developers at a fraction of the price.
A custom WordPress build with us starts from $15,000 ex GST. A developer capable of delivering the same thing in-house costs $155,000 to $195,000 a year fully loaded, and you carry that cost whether there is work in the pipeline or not.
A Care Plan at $2,500 a month is $30,000 a year. A fully loaded in-house developer is $155,000 or more. That is roughly one-fifth of the cost, for a team rather than one person.
2. You only need a developer for a specific project
If you are looking for someone to create a WordPress project only, then the best option is to go for an agency. Because agencies are great at working on projects. They will complete the project within the deadline and hand it over to you.
Since they already have experienced WordPress experts on board, you can expect a professionally developed website/store or anything else you are looking for.
3. Your project needs a team and not just a developer
Hiring a developer doesn’t make sense when your project needs the expertise of different experts. For instance, if you choose WP Creative for your eCommerce store, our team also consist of SEO experts who can provide their expertise in increasing visibility for your brand, which then increases sales.
In addition to building a website, our team will provide additional services like Technical SEO, Google Analytics Audit and even Website Security.
At the same time, you will not have to manage the developers and tell them what they should do on your site. If you are too busy managing your WordPress-based business, then you should aim for a development agency that can take care of the website for you.
4. You have a limited budget
A WordPress agency starts from $2,500 a month, against $155,000 to $195,000 a year for a fully loaded in-house developer.
When business owners have a limited budget for the development of their WordPress project/store, it is wise for them to go with a WordPress agency for their project development needs.
Since web development agencies provide you with a team of experts, which includes experts from different areas, you can get more done on a limited budget.
WP Creative consists of a team of expert developers, as well as quality analysts and SEO experts who will provide their insight for a fraction of the cost.
5. You don’t want to be the project manager
You can get a WordPress agency to work on your project if you don’t want complete control of the development. Many digital business owners are too busy working on their products.
They don’t have the budget or the time to control every aspect of the development process. So, in such a case, it makes sense to hire a WordPress agency for your business.
Once you have decided an agency is the right route, our seven checks for choosing a WordPress development partner covers what to hold them to.
When to Hire a WordPress Agency?
Agencies, as we have discussed earlier, have experts on board. Since they have a full-time job, they are looking for clients who have more money to spend. At WP Creative, our care plans start at just $2,500/month, which is extremely cost-effective when compared to hiring a developer.
That being said, if you are looking to get a complete website developed, your best bet would be a WordPress agency.
We have listed some of the reasons why you should go for a WordPress agency and not a freelancer. Here is when to make that choice.
1. When your project is complex and time-sensitive
Let’s say you want to create a WooCommerce eCommerce store. The WordPress agency will create a store from scratch, including its design, wireframes, programming, development, and launch.
You can even negotiate to get the best price from the WordPress agency. An eCommerce website can’t be developed by a WordPress freelancer alone because it is something that requires multiple things.
You would need a great hosting solution that can carry the weight of the eCommerce store. You would also need a great design so that your visitors can be attracted to your eCommerce store. Finally, you would need maintenance of your store in the first few months, if things break or don’t go according to plan.
WordPress agencies like WP Creative have a team of experts who will do the same job in a fraction of the cost as well as time. We even have local Wooexperts who develop WooCommerce sites in Melbourne and other regions in Australia.
If you’re in Victoria, explore our Geelong web development and Web Design Richmond services for local support.
2. When you want end-to-end management
Most clients want end-to-end involvement in their projects. This is something that WordPress freelancers can’t offer because they can’t stay on the phone with their clients and work on the project at the same time.
That is where agencies come in. WP Creative has a dedicated project manager who is working on maintaining client relationships. He/she keeps the client updated about everything from A to Z that is happening on the website.
It makes the client aware of the process and if everything is going according to plan. Or, if there are necessary changes needed, the client can call for them.
3. When You Want an Expert Team
A WordPress agency consists of a full team of specialists working together to make your website the best it can be. At WP Creative, you get seasoned developers, talented designers, QA experts, and even an SEO team that handles your marketing.
This means your site isn’t just functional, it’s beautifully designed, fully optimised, and built to perform. Instead of juggling multiple freelancers, you get a dedicated team that delivers results on multiple fronts.
When to Hire a WordPress Freelancer?
Australian freelance WordPress developers typically charge $45 to $70 an hour at mid level, and $75 to $120-plus for senior or specialist work. Entry level sits around $25 to $40. Anything advertised near $20 an hour is almost certainly offshore rather than Australian, which is a different decision with different risks.
You will find them on Upwork and Freelancer, and on WordPress-specific platforms like Codeable and Toptal.
But when hiring a freelancer, make sure that you know what type of work they will be doing for you.
1. When you have a one-off development job
We have already discussed that you can’t hire a freelancer for complex WordPress-related jobs because not everyone can do them. That is why you need to hire a WordPress developer only when the job is quick or doesn’t require your complete attention.
2. When you don’t want to commit long-term
Freelancers work on a project-by-project basis, so you get the flexibility to bring in help only when needed without long-term contracts or ongoing costs.
This is ideal for businesses that only require occasional updates, bug fixes, or minor feature additions. Instead of paying for a full team when you don’t need one, you can hire a freelancer for short-term tasks and move on once the job is done.
3. When you only want minute changes in your project
If you just need minor tweaks like fixing a broken button, adjusting a layout, or updating some content, a WordPress freelancer can get the job done quickly and affordably.
For example, if you only need to swap out images, tweak some CSS, or install a new custom plugin, hiring an entire agency or a full-time developer might be overkill. A freelancer is a great choice for these low-effort tasks that don’t require long-term support.
Every option comes with trade-offs in cost, strategy, and support. Read our comparison of WP Creative (WordPress specialist agency) vs freelancers vs generalist agencies to make a more informed decision.
Conclusion
Choosing between an in-house WordPress developer, an agency, or a freelancer depends on your specific needs, budget, and the complexity of your project.
If you want full control, quick communication, and regular maintenance, maintaining in-house resources is the way to go. However, if you’re working on a one-off project and are looking for cost efficiency, a WordPress agency might be a better fit. For smaller tasks or quick fixes, a freelancer can also be an affordable solution.
Ultimately, it’s about finding the right balance between cost, quality control, and the level of involvement you want. Consider your business goals, and choose the option that best supports them.
Ready to Hire a Trusted WordPress Agency?
We are rated the #1 WordPress development agency in Australia on Clutch, with 100+ five-star reviews behind it and trusted by 1200+ brands.
Our team of expert developers and designers has successfully delivered customised solutions for businesses across various industries, helping them achieve their digital goals.
We specialise in a full range of WordPress services that include website design from Camberwell to Melbourne and Sydney, WordPress development, WordPress maintenance and website security to ensure your website is not only visually stunning but also performs at its best
Looking to Hire WordPress Experts for Your Site Customisation? Book a Call Today
Get Your Free Website Audit
($3,000 Value)
- Uncover performance issues
- Identify SEO opportunities
- Security gaps, and quick wins
